Donal Trump
(Photo : Donal Trump / Instagram)
Donal Trump
  • Trump's sentencing in a criminal case has been delayed until after the 2024 presidential election by Judge Juan Merchan.
  • Trump was convicted on 34 counts of falsifying business records to cover up a hush money payment.
  • The delay is to avoid influencing the outcome of the presidential race and to respect the Supreme Court's immunity ruling.
  • The sentencing, if necessary, will occur on November 26, after the election.

In a significant development in the ongoing legal saga of former US President Donald Trump, a New York judge has decided to delay Trump's sentencing in a criminal case until after the 2024 presidential election.

The decision, announced by Judge Juan Merchan, is aimed at avoiding any appearance of influencing the outcome of the presidential race. Trump was convicted in May on 34 counts of falsifying business records to cover up a hush money payment to an adult-film star who alleged an affair with him. However, the sentencing has been on hold for months after Trump's lawyers pushed to have the conviction tossed based on the Supreme Court's ruling on presidential immunity.

Merchan's Decision and Trump's Response

In a four-page letter, Merchan explained his decision to delay the sentencing, stating that it was partly to dispel any suggestion that the court's decision or imposed sentence was intended to give an advantage to or create a disadvantage for any political party or candidate for any office. He further stated that he would sentence Trump on November 26, if necessary, in response to a request from Trump's lawyers to push back the sentencing.

Trump expressed appreciation for the language Merchan used in delaying his sentencing, noting that it will only commence if necessary. He argued that the case should be terminated immediately, falsely claiming that the sentencing was postponed because he did nothing wrong.

Implications of the Delay

In addition to pushing back the sentencing until November 26, Merchan wrote that he would decide on Trump's motion to vacate the verdict because of the Supreme Court's immunity decision on November 12, which is also after the election. He noted that the Supreme Court rendered a historic and intervening decision with its immunity ruling.

The decision to delay the sentencing marks yet another delay in Trump's criminal cases since he was indicted four times -- in New York, Florida, Washington, DC, and Georgia -- in 2023. The only indictment that went to trial this year was the New York hush money case that ended in the May guilty verdict. Now the sentencing in that trial -- with the question looming about whether a jail sentence will be imposed -- won't occur until after the election, if it happens at all.

Historical Context and Potential Outcomes

Merchan acknowledged the historic nature of Trump's hush money trial in his decision to push back the former President's sentencing until after the election. "Adjourning decision on the motion and sentencing, if such is required, should dispel any suggestion that the Court will have issued any decision or imposed sentence either to give an advantage to, or to create a disadvantage for, any political party and or any candidate for any office," Merchan wrote. 

The judge emphasized the importance of respecting the verdict of the jury and addressing it in a manner that is not diluted by the enormity of the upcoming presidential election. He also noted that if a sentencing hearing is necessary, the defendant has the right to a hearing that respects and protects his constitutional rights.

This case is reminiscent of the Watergate scandal that led to the resignation of President Richard Nixon in 1974. Nixon was never indicted or convicted, but several of his close associates were convicted of serious crimes. Like Nixon, Trump is facing serious legal challenges that could have significant political implications. However, unlike Nixon, Trump has been able to delay his legal proceedings, partly due to the Supreme Court's ruling on presidential immunity.

The delay means that Trump's criminal conviction -- which dominated both Trump's time and the news cycle during the spring - won't return to the forefront of the presidential campaign during the final weeks of the race. It also could mean that the election will not interfere with any sentence that Merchan might impose.

Trump could be sentenced to as much as four years of prison time, but Merchan is not required to sentence Trump to prison, and he could choose to impose a lesser sentence, such as probation, home confinement, community service or a fine.